Unveiling Europe

A veil has been lif­ted from Esto­nia. At least, that is what it feels like for this West-European walk­ing around in the coun­try after the European cur­rency has been intro­duced to its cit­izens. Some­how, Esto­nia sud­denly appears more ‘vis­ible’, as if a thin fog was cov­er­ing the small Baltic nation up until the first of Janu­ary 2011. Tak­ing the Neth­er­lands roughly as my geo­graph­ical ref­er­ence point of ‘home’, Esto­nia now feels a little ‘closer’ in the geo­graph­ical sense (or less remote, whichever way you prefer to put it). It has finally become a part of Europe as I appar­ently impli­citly con­ceive it.

Edit: WARNING: This post con­tains irony here and there.

Source: http://93rockon.com/news/articles/2010/ dec/31/estonia-joins-crisis-hit-euro-club/

My research is on vary­ing con­cep­tu­al­iz­a­tions of ‘Europe’. That is, I’m inter­ested in Europe as a social con­struc­tion across geo­graphy and social groups, and that goes bey­ond ‘just’ the polit­ical integ­ra­tion of large parts of the con­tin­ent. Doing a PhD at the EUI, I am nat­ur­ally often con­fron­ted with exactly this mis­con­cep­tion. If you’re doing research on how people feel about Europe, then fel­low research­ers quickly default into think­ing this means Euro­scep­ti­cism and polit­ical sup­port for the project.

I don’t blame them: the vague notion of ‘Europe’ and the rel­at­ively con­crete European Union pro­ject have become strongly entangled in our day-to-day speech and within our frames of ref­er­ence. So much, in fact, that it is hard to really sep­ar­ate the two without con­sist­ently emphas­iz­ing that you’re not only talk­ing about the EU and European polit­ical integ­ra­tion, but about people’s rather vague notions of Europe more broadly.

As a res­ult, I think I have been down­play­ing to oth­ers and myself just how import­ant people’s ima­gin­a­tions of ‘Europe’ have been to polit­ical integ­ra­tion, and more import­antly the other way around: how import­ant polit­ical (and in this case mon­et­ary) integ­ra­tion has been to people’s con­cep­tu­al­iz­a­tion of ‘Europe’.

Partly as a res­ult of work­ing on my research topic, partly per­haps due to pre­sump­tu­ous­ness, I used to think of myself as reas­on­ably detached from ‘Western-Europe-centric’ think­ing. I used to think of myself not primar­ily as Western-European, and recently prob­ably not even as (just) ‘European’ (and ‘Dutch’ has never really applied to me, but that’s for another blog post). I have spent quite a lot of time in Cent­ral and East­ern Europe (mostly in Poland and Esto­nia), and always find myself try­ing to redefine people’s Western-centric world­views when I’m back in the Netherlands.

How­ever, as my feel­ings after the Euro was wel­comed to Esto­nia have shown me, the polit­ical integ­ra­tion of Europe clearly has shaped my con­cep­tu­al­iz­a­tion of what ‘Europe’ is. And though I am ashamed to admit it, it has affected my impli­cit ideas on centre and peri­phery. The Soviet Union col­lapsed, the EU expan­ded to the East, Esto­nia joined Schen­gen, and now the coun­try finally became a full mem­ber of ‘Europe’ with the intro­duc­tion of the European cur­rency. Now, as I watch the Esto­nian shop­keep­ers and cof­fee vendors clum­sily count their first Euro’s, the coun­try slowly starts to demys­tify before my eyes and some­how feels more and more like ‘home’.

Jer­oen Moes is a PhD researcher at the European Uni­ver­sity Insti­tute, Florence. His research focuses on con­cep­tu­al­iz­a­tions of ‘Europe’ across the con­tin­ent with in-depth case stud­ies in Esto­nia, Italy, and the Neth­er­lands. He employs a meth­od­o­lo­gic­ally mixed approach by com­bin­ing large N stat­ist­ical ana­lyses with small N in-depth qual­it­at­ive research. More on his research pro­ject can be found on the ‘Ima­gin­ing Europe’ web­site (www.Imagining.eu).

4 Comments

  • I have reacted to your post here http://ricemagic.blogspot.com/2011/01/how-much-european-is-someone-elses.html

    Of course, my post is NOT an attack on you, etc..

    now the coun­try finally became a full mem­ber of ‘Europe’ with the intro­duc­tion of the European cur­rency”: you really do way tooooooooooooooooo much import­ance on this com­mon cur­rency thing. Do you real­ize there are still many EU-27 coun­tries not in the Euro area (not to men­tion European coun­tries out­side the EU)? And do you real­ize there are coun­tries that don’t want to join the euro, or may never want, oth­ers that may con­sider leav­ing the euro zone, and oth­ers still that might be politely asked to leave? If there is a thing on which Europe (big pic­ture concept) is not based and, appar­ently will never be, is the Euro…

    • Hi Ricardo,

      Thanks for your com­ment! I replied to your own blog post here: http://www.imagining.eu/blog/2011/01/europe-as-a-touchy-topic/
      I invite you to reflect on it when you find the time.

      In brief: clearly you missed the irony of my post (see the added dis­claimer above). I have never before been called an ignor­ant Western-European nation­al­ist (as you do in your post), and I think for good reas­ons. In fact, my point above was not that the Euro defines ‘Europe’ in any formal sense (and I am very much aware of which coun­tries do or do not have/want the Euro, thank you very much). My point was that even as a social sci­ent­ist study­ing con­cep­tu­al­iz­a­tions of Europe more broadly, one can­not escape the influ­ence that insti­tu­tions like the EU or the Euro have on how one con­cep­tu­al­izes Europe. I used to deny that (as you do, appar­ently), but it is some­thing that should be con­sidered as well. That says noth­ing about whether I think a coun­try ‘is European’ or not (or to what extent).

      I wel­come you to read my reply on my other blog (this is a col­lab­or­at­ive blog and I don’t want to clut­ter it), and share your follow-up thoughts with me.

  • […] cur­rently work­ing on my PhD dis­ser­ta­tion. To try and give a first stim­u­lus to the site, I also con­trib­uted a blog post of my own, based on some unex­pec­ted feel­ings I per­son­ally had when the Euro was intro­duced here in Estonia […]

  • Angelina Doherty wrote:

    Good art­icle!

    New mem­bers to the Euro seem con­fid­ent it will work somehow.

    Here is an inter­view with Estonia’s Fin­ance Minister…

    http://theeuropean-magazine.com/164-ligi-juergen/165-introduction-of-the-euro-in-estonia

Post a Comment

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *